I need your help! I am so confused right now. I’ve been dating a girl for three weeks now and two nights ago, after we finally became intimate, she suggested I “switch out” and dater her twin sister instead. I thought this girl and I were really hitting it off but she said she wasn’t into it, so she wanted to make sure I was going to be able to be with someone I was still attracted to. I left that night not knowing what to say, and I still don’t really know what to do. Was I just auditioning to date this girl’s sister? Did this girl ever really care about me? What gives?
This is the part where I’m supposed to tell you this is how some porn movies start, but I just can’t bring myself to say it. This is just CREEPY. I can’t even to begin to guess why this girl wants you to date her sister. It’d be one thing if she wasn’t into you and later on you ended up dating her sister, but to have her actually suggest her sister as an alternative is just plain weird. Forget the fact that you once liked this girl, just back away…back away now, before this gets even more odd. You deserve better, and even if the sister is better, you deserve better than that.